Are Gummies as Good as Pills?
Nah, not really. Gummies typically have 30-50% less of the actual vitamin compared to pills. Plus added sugar. Plus they go bad faster. You're basically buying expensive candy that happens to contain some vitamins.
The Numbers
How much scientific truth is there?
How much is just marketing?
Marketing vs Reality
What Marketing Says
- "Same nutrition, now in delicious gummy form!"
- "Finally, vitamins you'll actually want to take"
- "Kids and adults both love them"
- "Easy on sensitive stomachs"
What Science Says
- ConsumerLab has tested a bunch of gummy vitamins. Many contained less than what the label promised. Not great.
- Gummies degrade faster than pills. Heat and humidity mess them up. That bottle in your bathroom cabinet? Probably losing potency.
- Here's the physics problem: to make something gummy, you need gelatin, pectin, sweeteners, flavors. All that takes up space that could be vitamins.
- Sugar content runs 2-8 grams per serving. Multiply that by daily use and... yeah, you're eating candy.
Reality Check
Look, I get it. Pills suck. Some people gag on them, can't swallow them, hate them. Gummies solve that problem. But you're trading convenience for potency. A capsule can hold more stuff. A gummy has to be mostly gummy. That's just how it works.
What To Do Instead
- 1If you can handle pills, just take pills. Better dose, cheaper per serving, longer shelf life.
- 2If gummies are your only option, look for third-party tested brands. ConsumerLab, USP, NSF certified.
- 3Consider taking two gummies when the label says one. Know they're probably underdosed anyway.
- 4Liquid vitamins exist too. Might be worth trying if you hate both pills and gummies.
The Exception
For kids who absolutely refuse pills? Gummies beat nothing. And some premium brands actually hit their label claims. But you have to check. Don't assume.
The Bottom Line
Gummies are vitamin candy. They deliver some benefit, just less efficiently. If you can swallow pills, do that.
Related Supplements
But Wait...
Physics. A gummy needs to be mostly gelatin/pectin, sweetener, and flavoring to have that texture. You can't make a vitamin pill gummy. It would be a rock.
More Myths to Bust
About this information: Our recommendations draw from peer-reviewed clinical trials, systematic reviews, and the same medical databases your doctor uses. These statements have not been evaluated by the FDA. Supplements are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease.
Get Science-Backed Supplement Tips
Weekly insights from 47,000+ clinical trials
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime. We respect your inbox.
Want To Check Your Own Supplements?
Find out if your stack is legit or expensive pee.
Analyze Your Stack