What's the deal with folic acid vs methylfolate?

About 30-40% of people have MTHFR mutations making it harder to convert folic acid. Methylfolate bypasses this. Worth the premium if you're in that group.

Are "whole food" vitamins better?

Usually not. They're often underdosed and overpriced. You'd need many pills to match a standard supplement's dose. Marketing over science.

HEAD-TO-HEAD12,100/month searches

47,000+ trials analyzed

59,000+ interactions

Not FDA evaluated

Synthetic vs Natural Vitamins

Does the source actually matter?

THE WINNERIt Depends

Natural vitamin E (d-alpha) beats synthetic (dl-alpha). Methylfolate beats folic acid for some people. For everything else, synthetic is chemically identical and much cheaper. Don't pay 5x more for "natural" vitamin C.

Head-to-Head Comparison

Synthetic Vitamins

BioavailabilityVaries (usually good)

Cost$

Time to WorkSame as natural

Best For

Consistent dosingLower costMost supplementation needsPurity

Not Best For

Vitamin EFolate for some peopleWhole food purists

Side Effects

Same as natural for most

Key Fact: Chemically identical to natural for most vitamins. Your body can't tell the difference. Manufactured in controlled conditions.

Natural Vitamins

BioavailabilityVaries (sometimes better)

Cost$$$

Time to WorkSame as synthetic

Best For

Vitamin E (clearly better)Folate (methylfolate)Whole food approach fans

Not Best For

Budget consciousNeeding high dosesPurity concerns

Side Effects

Same as synthetic for most

Key Fact: Vitamin E from natural sources is 2x better retained. Methylfolate beats folic acid for many. Otherwise, difference is minimal.

Which One For Your Goal?

Your Goal	Winner	Why
Vitamin E	Natural	d-alpha-tocopherol has 2x retention
Folate	Natural (methylfolate)	Works better for MTHFR mutations
Vitamin C	Either	Chemically identical molecules
B vitamins	Either	No meaningful difference
Vitamin D	Either	D3 is D3 regardless of source
Budget	Synthetic	3-10x cheaper
Purity/consistency	Synthetic	Better quality control

Myth vs Reality

Myth: "Your body knows the difference between natural and synthetic." Reality: A molecule is a molecule. Ascorbic acid from an orange is identical to ascorbic acid from a lab. Your cells can't distinguish the source.

Why It Depends Sometimes

For vitamin E: natural wins definitively (2x better retention). For folate: methylfolate is better for those with MTHFR mutations. For vitamin C, B vitamins, D3, minerals? No meaningful difference. Your body doesn't care.

Common Questions

d-alpha-tocopherol = natural. dl-alpha-tocopherol = synthetic. That "l" makes a big difference. Check the label.

The Bottom Line

Pay more for natural vitamin E and methylfolate. For everything else, synthetic is fine. The "natural is better" marketing costs you money without improving your health.

More Showdowns

Vitamin D2 Vs D3 Liposomal Vs Regular Vitamins

About this information: Our recommendations draw from peer-reviewed clinical trials, systematic reviews, and the same medical databases your doctor uses. These statements have not been evaluated by the FDA. Supplements are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease.

Strong Evidence

Get Science-Backed Supplement Tips

Weekly insights from 47,000+ clinical trials

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime. We respect your inbox.

Check Your Full Stack

See how all your supplements work together.

Analyze My Stack