Is Your Stack Actually Working?
How to know if your supplements are doing anything
TL;DR
Most people can't objectively evaluate their supplement stack. Track specific metrics, not feelings. Test before and after. Give supplements proper time. And be honest: if nothing changes after 3 months, something isn't working.
The Placebo Problem
You spent money on something. You want it to work. This creates powerful bias. Studies show people report benefits from supplements even when given sugar pills. Not because they're stupid. Because brains are wired to confirm expectations. You can't trust "feeling better" alone.
Key Takeaway: Your brain wants to justify the purchase. Don't rely on feelings alone.
What to Actually Track
Objective measures beat subjective feelings. For energy supplements: track actual sleep duration and quality with an app. For stress supplements: measure resting heart rate trends. For cognitive supplements: use free online tests weekly (Cambridge Brain Sciences, for example). Numbers don't lie to make you feel better.
Key Takeaway: Track metrics, not vibes. Numbers reveal truth.
The Baseline Test
Can't evaluate change without knowing where you started. Before adding a new supplement: establish 2 weeks of baseline data. Track whatever you're hoping to improve. Then add the supplement. Compare the next 4-8 weeks to your baseline. Without this, you're guessing.
Key Takeaway: No baseline means no way to measure change.
The Removal Test
Here's one most people skip. Stop taking a supplement for 2-4 weeks. See what happens. If nothing changes, that supplement wasn't doing much. This is uncomfortable because it might reveal you've been wasting money. But better to know than to keep wasting.
Key Takeaway: If removing it changes nothing, it wasn't helping.
Give It Proper Time
Some supplements need time to work. Creatine takes 2-4 weeks to saturate muscles. Fish oil takes 6-8 weeks for measurable inflammation changes. Vitamin D can take 8-12 weeks to reach optimal levels. If you're judging after 1 week, you're not being fair.
The Stack Audit Process
Every 6 months, audit your full stack. Question every bottle: What am I hoping this does? Is there evidence it works for that? Have I noticed actual changes? Would I rebuy if it ran out? Any supplement that can't pass all four questions should go.
Key Takeaway: Regular audits prevent expensive supplement creep.
Real Talk
Most supplement stacks contain at least one thing that isn't doing anything. Maybe it worked for someone else. Maybe you bought it based on marketing. Maybe the dose is too low. Finding that wasted money requires honesty that most people avoid. But that $15/month times 12 months adds up fast.
What To Do About It
- Track specific metrics for each supplement's claimed benefit
- Establish baselines before adding new supplements
- Try removing supplements one at a time to test necessity
- Give new supplements 4-8 weeks minimum before judging
- Audit your full stack every 6 months
- Be willing to cut what isn't working
The Bottom Line
The only stack worth taking is one that actually works. Test yours.
More Real Talk
About this information: Our recommendations draw from peer-reviewed clinical trials, systematic reviews, and the same medical databases your doctor uses. These statements have not been evaluated by the FDA. Supplements are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease.
Get Science-Backed Supplement Tips
Weekly insights from 47,000+ clinical trials
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime. We respect your inbox.
Ready to Check Your Stack?
Find out if your supplements are the real deal or marketing noise.
Analyze My Stack